| 1985 | #12-Kentucky | #5-Washington |
| 1986 | #12-DePaul | #5-Virginia |
| 1987 | #12-Wyoming | #5-Virginia |
| 1989 | #12-DePaul | #5-Memphis |
| 1990 | #12-Dayton | #5-Illinois |
| 1990 | #12-Ball State | #5-Oregon State |
| 1991 | #12-Eastern Michigan | #5-Mississippi State |
| 1992 | #12-New Mexico State | #5-DePaul |
| 1993 | #12-George Washington | #5-New Mexico |
| 1994 | #12-Wisconsin-Green Bay | #5-California |
| 1994 | #12-Tulsa | #5-UCLA |
| 1995 | #12-Miami-OH | #5-Arizona |
| 1996 | #12-Arkansas | #5-Penn State |
| 1996 | #12-Drexel | #5-Memphis |
| 1997 | #12-College of Charleston | #5-Maryland |
| 1998 | #12-Florida State | #5-TCU |
| 1999 | #12-Detroit | #5-UCLA |
| 1999 | #12-Missouri State | #5-Wisconsin |
| 2001 | #12-Gonzaga | #5-Virginia |
| 2001 | #12-Utah State | #5-Ohio State |
| 2002 | #12-Missouri | #5-Miami-FL |
| 2002 | #12-Tulsa | #5-Marquette |
| 2002 | #12-Creighton | #5-Florida |
| 2003 | #12-Butler | #5-Mississippi State |
| 2004 | #12-Pacific | #5-Providence |
| 2004 | #12-Manhattan | #5-Florida |
| 2005 | #12-Wisc-Milwaukee | #5-Alabama |
| 2006 | #12-Montana | #5-Nevada |
| 2006 | #12-Texas A&M | #5-Syracuse |
| 2008 | #12-Western Kentucky | #5-Drake |
| 2008 | #12-Villanova | #5-Clemson |
| 2009 | #12-Wisconsin | #5-Florida State |
| 2009 | #12-Western Kentucky | #5-Illinois |
| 2009 | #12-Arizona | #5-Utah |
| 2010 | #12-Cornell | #5-Temple |
| 2011 | #12-Richmond | #5-Vanderbilt |
| 2012 | #12-VCU | #5-Wichita State |
| 2012 | #12-South Florida | #5-Temple |
| 2013 | #12-California | #5-UNLV |
| 2013 | #12-Oregon | #5-Oklahoma State |
| 2013 | #12-Mississippi | #5-Wisconsin |
| 2014 | #12-North Dakota St | #5-Oklahoma |
| 2014 | #12-Stephen F. Austin | #5-VCU |
| 2014 | #12-Harvard | #5-Cincinnati |
| 2016 | #12-Yale | #5-Baylor |
| 2016 | #12-Arkansas Little Rock | #5-Purdue |
| 2017 | #12-Middle Tennessee State | #5-Minnesota |
| 2019 | #12-Oregon | #5-Wisconsin |
| 2019 | #12-Murray State | #5-Marquette |
| 2019 | #12-Liberty | #5-Mississippi State |
| 2021 | #12-Oregon State | #5-Tennessee |
| 2022 | #12-Richmond | #5-Iowa |
| 2022 | #12-New Mexico State | #5-Connecticut |
| 2024 | #12-Grand Canyon | #5-St Marys (CA) |
| 2024 | #12-James Madison | #5-Wisconsin |
| 2025 | #12-Colorado State | #5-Memphis |
| 2025 | #12-McNeese | #5-Clemson |