| 1985 | #1-St Johns | #16-Southern |
| 1985 | #1-Georgetown | #16-Lehigh |
| 1985 | #1-Michigan | #16-Fairleigh Dickinson |
| 1985 | #1-Oklahoma | #16-North Carolina A&T |
| 1986 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Davidson |
| 1986 | #1-St Johns | #16-Montana State |
| 1986 | #1-Kansas | #16-North Carolina A&T |
| 1986 | #1-Duke | #16-Mississippi Valley State |
| 1987 | #1-Georgetown | #16-Bucknell |
| 1987 | #1-UNLV | #16-Idaho State |
| 1987 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Pennsylvania |
| 1987 | #1-Indiana | #16-Fairfield |
| 1988 | #1-Purdue | #16-Fairleigh Dickinson |
| 1988 | #1-Oklahoma | #16-Chattanooga |
| 1988 | #1-Arizona | #16-Cornell |
| 1988 | #1-Temple | #16-Lehigh |
| 1989 | #1-Arizona | #16-Robert Morris |
| 1989 | #1-Georgetown | #16-Princeton |
| 1989 | #1-Oklahoma | #16-East Tennessee State |
| 1989 | #1-Illinois | #16-McNeese |
| 1990 | #1-UNLV | #16-Arkansas Little Rock |
| 1990 | #1-Oklahoma | #16-Towson |
| 1990 | #1-Michigan State | #16-Murray State |
| 1990 | #1-Connecticut | #16-Boston University |
| 1991 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Northeastern |
| 1991 | #1-Arkansas | #16-Georgia St |
| 1991 | #1-UNLV | #16-Montana |
| 1991 | #1-Ohio State | #16-Towson |
| 1992 | #1-Ohio State | #16-Mississippi Valley State |
| 1992 | #1-Kansas | #16-Howard |
| 1992 | #1-Duke | #16-Campbell |
| 1992 | #1-UCLA | #16-Robert Morris |
| 1993 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Rider |
| 1993 | #1-Michigan | #16-Coastal Carolina |
| 1993 | #1-North Carolina | #16-East Carolina |
| 1993 | #1-Indiana | #16-Wright St |
| 1994 | #1-Missouri | #16-Navy |
| 1994 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Liberty |
| 1994 | #1-Arkansas | #16-North Carolina A&T |
| 1994 | #1-Purdue | #16-Central Florida |
| 1995 | #1-UCLA | #16-Florida Intl |
| 1995 | #1-Wake Forest | #16-North Carolina A&T |
| 1995 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Mount St Marys |
| 1995 | #1-Kansas | #16-Colgate |
| 1996 | #1-Kentucky | #16-San Jose State |
| 1996 | #1-Connecticut | #16-Colgate |
| 1996 | #1-Purdue | #16-Western Carolina |
| 1996 | #1-Massachusetts | #16-Central Florida |
| 1997 | #1-Minnesota | #16-Texas St |
| 1997 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Fairfield |
| 1997 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Montana |
| 1997 | #1-Kansas | #16-Jackson State |
| 1998 | #1-Duke | #16-Radford |
| 1998 | #1-Kansas | #16-Prairie View |
| 1998 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Navy |
| 1998 | #1-Arizona | #16-Nicholls State |
| 1999 | #1-Auburn | #16-Winthrop |
| 1999 | #1-Connecticut | #16-Texas-San Antonio |
| 1999 | #1-Duke | #16-Florida A&M |
| 1999 | #1-Michigan State | #16-Mount St Marys |
| 2000 | #1-Stanford | #16-South Carolina State |
| 2000 | #1-Arizona | #16-Jackson State |
| 2000 | #1-Duke | #16-Lamar |
| 2000 | #1-Michigan State | #16-Valparaiso |
| 2001 | #1-Stanford | #16-NC-Greensboro |
| 2001 | #1-Duke | #16-Monmouth |
| 2001 | #1-Illinois | #16-Northwestern State |
| 2001 | #1-Michigan State | #16-Alabama State |
| 2002 | #1-Duke | #16-Winthrop |
| 2002 | #1-Maryland | #16-Siena |
| 2002 | #1-Cincinnati | #16-Boston University |
| 2002 | #1-Kansas | #16-Holy Cross |
| 2003 | #1-Arizona | #16-Vermont |
| 2003 | #1-Oklahoma | #16-South Carolina State |
| 2003 | #1-Texas | #16-NC-Asheville |
| 2003 | #1-Kentucky | #16-IUPUI |
| 2004 | #1-Saint Josephs | #16-Liberty |
| 2004 | #1-Stanford | #16-Texas-San Antonio |
| 2004 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Florida A&M |
| 2004 | #1-Duke | #16-Alabama State |
| 2005 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Oakland |
| 2005 | #1-Duke | #16-Delaware State |
| 2005 | #1-Illinois | #16-Fairleigh Dickinson |
| 2005 | #1-Washington | #16-Montana |
| 2006 | #1-Duke | #16-Southern |
| 2006 | #1-Connecticut | #16-Albany |
| 2006 | #1-Memphis | #16-Oral Roberts |
| 2006 | #1-Villanova | #16-Monmouth |
| 2007 | #1-Kansas | #16-Niagara |
| 2007 | #1-Ohio State | #16-Central Connecticut St |
| 2007 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Eastern Kentucky |
| 2007 | #1-Florida | #16-Jackson State |
| 2008 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Mount St Marys |
| 2008 | #1-Kansas | #16-Portland State |
| 2008 | #1-Memphis | #16-Texas Arlington |
| 2008 | #1-UCLA | #16-Mississippi Valley State |
| 2009 | #1-Pittsburgh | #16-East Tennessee State |
| 2009 | #1-Louisville | #16-Morehead State |
| 2009 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Radford |
| 2009 | #1-Connecticut | #16-Chattanooga |
| 2010 | #1-Kentucky | #16-East Tennessee State |
| 2010 | #1-Duke | #16-Ark Pine Bluff |
| 2010 | #1-Syracuse | #16-Vermont |
| 2010 | #1-Kansas | #16-Lehigh |
| 2011 | #1-Kansas | #16-Boston University |
| 2011 | #1-Ohio State | #16-Texas-San Antonio |
| 2011 | #1-Pittsburgh | #16-NC-Asheville |
| 2011 | #1-Duke | #16-Hampton |
| 2012 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Vermont |
| 2012 | #1-Syracuse | #16-NC-Asheville |
| 2012 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Western Kentucky |
| 2012 | #1-Michigan State | #16-LIU Brooklyn |
| 2013 | #1-Kansas | #16-Western Kentucky |
| 2013 | #1-Louisville | #16-North Carolina A&T |
| 2013 | #1-Gonzaga | #16-Southern |
| 2013 | #1-Indiana | #16-James Madison |
| 2014 | #1-Florida | #16-Albany |
| 2014 | #1-Wichita State | #16-Cal Poly |
| 2014 | #1-Arizona | #16-Weber State |
| 2014 | #1-Virginia | #16-Coastal Carolina |
| 2015 | #1-Duke | #16-Robert Morris |
| 2015 | #1-Wisconsin | #16-Coastal Carolina |
| 2015 | #1-Kentucky | #16-Hampton |
| 2015 | #1-Villanova | #16-Lafayette |
| 2016 | #1-Oregon | #16-Holy Cross |
| 2016 | #1-Kansas | #16-Austin Peay |
| 2016 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Florida Gulf Coast |
| 2016 | #1-Virginia | #16-Hampton |
| 2017 | #1-Kansas | #16-UC Davis |
| 2017 | #1-Villanova | #16-Mount St Marys |
| 2017 | #1-Gonzaga | #16-South Dakota State |
| 2017 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Texas Southern |
| 2018 | #1-Xavier | #16-Texas Southern |
| 2018 | #1-Villanova | #16-Radford |
| 2018 | #1-Kansas | #16-Pennsylvania |
| 2019 | #1-Virginia | #16-Gardner Webb |
| 2019 | #1-Gonzaga | #16-Fairleigh Dickinson |
| 2019 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Iona |
| 2019 | #1-Duke | #16-North Dakota St |
| 2021 | #1-Baylor | #16-Hartford |
| 2021 | #1-Michigan | #16-Texas Southern |
| 2021 | #1-Illinois | #16-Drexel |
| 2021 | #1-Gonzaga | #16-Norfolk State |
| 2022 | #1-Kansas | #16-Texas Southern |
| 2022 | #1-Gonzaga | #16-Georgia St |
| 2022 | #1-Baylor | #16-Norfolk State |
| 2022 | #1-Arizona | #16-Wright St |
| 2023 | #1-Alabama | #16-TX A&M Corp Chris |
| 2023 | #1-Kansas | #16-Howard |
| 2023 | #1-Houston | #16-Northern Kentucky |
| 2024 | #1-Houston | #16-Longwood |
| 2024 | #1-North Carolina | #16-Wagner |
| 2024 | #1-Connecticut | #16-Stetson |
| 2024 | #1-Purdue | #16-Grambling |
| 2025 | #1-Duke | #16-Mount St Marys |
| 2025 | #1-Florida | #16-Norfolk State |
| 2025 | #1-Auburn | #16-Alabama State |
| 2025 | #1-Houston | #16-SIU-Edwardsville |